Patriotism: A Covertly Placed Social Scam

Disclaimer: The following post is my personal opinion and I have no intentions of getting into a debate or discussion with anyone on a public and/or online platform. Feel free to contact me in person, if you’re too keen.

Loosely speaking, Patriotism is one of the many concepts we’ve been fed and forced and taught to believe at face value since school. From parents who just focus on building wealth so as to see our future be what their idea of “secure” is; to media who claim to unmask all that is wrong and unethical and inhumane around the world but pragmatically have deluged too deeply into competing with rival media houses for more coverage and viewership; to the politicians, who manipulate and fill their pockets while beaming showcasing themselves to be the representatives of the goodwill and benefit of all those living on a specific piece of land; everyone who bears even a faintest attachment to their country would renounce you as their comrade, friend, companion if you for once said you’re not really patriotic irrespective of your nationality (referring to fairly stable countries only, can’t stay about the rest).

A learning mechanism which most schools teach at an early stage is by questioning everything, asking why. But how many of us, asked the teachers, why? Why are we supposed to question everything? To learn and understand the world better, a fairly logical argument. I could go at lengths on how’s that also a flawed comeback if scrutinized carefully, but let’s cut them some slack at this point.

So when we’re taught: we have been grown up, we owe our existence to the healthy soil of Mother India and the hand work and enterprise of my beloved fellow Indians, people of my beloved country, so we must give back in whichever way possible, by respecting our country, by contributing our part in helping someone else be fed and educated in another corner of the same nation.

(I don’t really buy that personally. Why this fake sense of attachment to someone you’ve not met? For all I know, that farmer might be a part-time rapist. Not that everyone I have met is not, I have my reservations about them too.)

Anyway, Why? Why is it “Mother India” and not “Mother Earth” who has fed us? Why is not a fellow human being, not Indian who toiled in the sun so that we ate supper tonight? Why?

What has boundaries got us, anyway? Only complications. Only reasons for the powerful to manipulate us, the mere naive innocent “citizens”, notwithstanding or even trying to fathom the spiral of affairs that decides the fate and future of a nation, its economy and well-being.

Sure, the world is now becoming more and more globalized, but I’m sure you’d be delighted to find another Indian (or someone from your nationality or neighborhood) when you’re away in Belarus (or any other “foreign country”). Must be some, innately humane thing (beyond my mental grasp). But I ask you why? Is that the most optimal point we get at. Wouldn’t it be easier to just feel associated with someone by the proximity of his homeland to yours? (Please ignore if you don’t understand this, I might be too sleepy to write lucidly. Pardon me.)

Coming to wars, just because that guy is from another country, you got a right to shoot him in his head? These are the morals we’re feeding into our minds with this hollow, deceptive and remotely-satiating-the-thirst-for-pride-sometimes notion: patriotism. Is he not another one, just like you, leaving his family back with the illusioned idea of keeping the country above his own. What for? For some piece of land that will always be meant for battles, firing, and blood? (Yes, I had Kashmir in mind, when I wrote this) Someone who has lost his/her closed one in such encounters would demand revenge, only to be “fair”. But why friend, when has life been fair?

Patriotism. I say, bull-shit. If your sense of right-and-wrong, your ethics and morals were so uptight, you would question the whole idea yourself? Not that, I’m endorsing myself to be one. Also, I do not detest the idea of dead people. Some people are lucky to be being dead prematurely. And for others, the world’s a better place without them. But coaxing such an evidently fiercely barbaric act into something heroic, I don’t know, I believe being incredulous is only natural of me.


4 thoughts on “Patriotism: A Covertly Placed Social Scam”

  1. Why we should be grateful for our soil, Mother India?
    Ask an illegal immigrant, a refugee. This idea may seem useless to you who has the freedom to live in and travel to any place.
    Why we should give back to everyone less fortunate, even the rapist?
    I know easier said than done. You know why rapists may be rapists? Apart from the genetic tendency to violence and perversion (nature), a lot has to do with the environment (nurture). So you and I may be rapists if we are constantly in environments that induce anxiety and sadness. Those guys are more prone because of the added disadvantage of lacking the basic human rights/needs.
    We don’t shoot random guys from another country, battlefield is a different scenario (I so wish that it didn’t exist at all, there I see room for development. Having an army is ok, but the wars not.)
    But at the end, pride in anything is okay so long as it can be contained (although ideally, one should not have any pride.) Patriotism could be a tool to make sure ppl are not ashamed of their countries, and help make it better; but just like religion, ppl use it as a means of power of others.

    (sorry for such a long comment, it just shows I read your article with interest 😀 )

  2. I fully appreciate the argument and 100% agree with you on this. I guess patriotism has been developed to harness collective strength and in self – defense and later evolved into the monster we perceive today.
    If I may, I would like to point you towards Animal Farm by George Orwell, which takes the analogy of an animal farm to illustrate the evolution of human societies. That might throw some light on lot of unasked questions in this article.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s